LoginRegister
CITI Universitywww.citi.edu.mn ↗
CITI SCIENCE 
International Scholarly Journal
ISSN (Print): 2788-7685e-ISSN (Online): 2788-7693Published by CITI University
Submit Manuscript
CITI Science Journal

Corrections, Retractions, and Appeals Policy

CITI Science Journal is committed to maintaining the accuracy, integrity, and reliability of the scholarly record. The journal takes appropriate action when errors, concerns about research integrity, or disputes regarding editorial decisions arise. This policy establishes procedures for correcting published articles, retracting unreliable research, issuing expressions of concern where necessary, and considering appeals against editorial decisions.

Corrections

The journal may publish a correction when an error is identified in a published article and the error requires formal clarification or amendment to maintain the accuracy of the scholarly record. Corrections may address errors such as inaccurate author information, affiliations, acknowledgments, funding details, typographical errors affecting meaning, or errors in figures, tables, data presentation, or other content that can be corrected without invalidating the overall findings or conclusions.

Requests for corrections may be submitted by authors, readers, editors, or other relevant parties. The editorial team will assess the reported error and determine whether a correction is necessary. Published corrections will clearly identify the article concerned, describe the correction, and be linked to the original article where practicable. The original publication record will be maintained transparently.

Retractions

The journal may retract a published article when there is clear evidence that its findings or conclusions are unreliable, or when serious publication ethics violations have occurred. Grounds for retraction may include, but are not limited to:

  • Fabrication or falsification of research data or results.
  • Plagiarism or substantial unattributed use of others' work.
  • Duplicate or redundant publication that materially misrepresents the scholarly record.<o:p></o:p>
  • Serious errors that invalidate the findings or conclusions.<o:p></o:p>
  • Unethical research practices or serious violations of applicable research ethics requirements.<o:p></o:p>
  • Manipulation of the peer-review or publication process.<o:p></o:p>
  • Other substantiated forms of misconduct that seriously compromise the integrity of the article.

Retraction is intended to correct the scholarly record and does not necessarily imply that all authors were involved in misconduct. Before making a retraction decision, the journal will assess the available evidence and, where appropriate, seek explanations from the authors and relevant institutions. The journal may proceed when justified by the evidence, even if the authors do not agree with the decision or do not respond.

A retraction notice will identify the article, explain the reason for retraction as clearly as appropriate, and indicate who is issuing the notice. The retraction notice will be linked to the original article. Where practicable, the original article will remain accessible with a clear retraction statement so that the publication history remains transparent.

Expressions of Concern

When credible concerns arise about a published article but an investigation has not yet reached a conclusion, the journal may publish an expression of concern. An expression of concern may be issued when the available evidence raises significant questions about the reliability or integrity of an article and further investigation is required. The journal will review the matter as additional information becomes available and may subsequently issue a correction, retract the article, or take no further action, depending on the findings.

Initiating a Post-Publication Review

Concerns about a published article may be raised by authors, readers, reviewers, editors, institutions, or other parties with relevant information. Reports should provide sufficient details and supporting evidence to allow the journal to assess the concern. The editorial team will review the information fairly and confidentially to the extent appropriate. Where necessary, the journal may contact the authors, request supporting materials, consult independent experts, or communicate with relevant institutions. The journal will consider the evidence available and take action proportionate to the seriousness of the concern.

Appeals Against Editorial Decisions

Authors may appeal an editorial decision if they believe that a significant factual error, a material misunderstanding of the manuscript, a procedural irregularity, or an identifiable conflict of interest affected the decision. Appeals must be submitted in writing to the editorial office and should include:

  • The manuscript title, article's DOI record and reference number, if available.
  • The editorial decision being appealed.
  • A clear explanation of the grounds for the appeal.
  • Relevant supporting evidence or documentation.

Disagreement with a decision alone, without substantive grounds, may not be sufficient to justify reconsideration. The Editor-in-Chief or an independent editor who was not responsible for the original decision will review the appeal, where practicable. Additional expert advice may be sought when necessary.

The journal may uphold the original decision, reconsider the manuscript, request further review, or take other appropriate action. The outcome of the appeal will be communicated to the corresponding author. The journal's appeal decision is final within its editorial process.

Responsibilities of Authors

Authors are expected to cooperate with reasonable requests for clarification, supporting data, or documentation concerning potential errors or integrity concerns. Authors who identify a significant error in their published work should notify the editorial office promptly and cooperate in determining the appropriate corrective action. Requests for corrections, retractions, or appeals must be made in good faith and supported by accurate information.

Transparency and Publication Record

The journal will document decisions concerning corrections, retractions, and expressions of concern and will provide appropriate notices to readers. Where practicable, notices will be linked to the relevant article and the article's DOI record will be updated as appropriate. The journal aims to preserve the transparency and integrity of the scholarly record while respecting confidentiality and applicable legal requirements.

Implementation

The Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor is responsible for overseeing the implementation of this policy. All cases will be assessed individually, taking into account the available evidence, the seriousness of the issue, and relevant publication ethics principles.