Plagiarism and Similarity Screening Policy
CITI Science Journal is committed to maintaining academic integrity and ensuring that all published work meets appropriate standards of originality, proper attribution, and responsible scholarly practice. The journal screens submitted manuscripts for potential plagiarism, inappropriate text reuse, duplicate publication, and other forms of publication misconduct. This policy applies to all manuscript types considered by the journal.
Initial Similarity Screening
All submissions must be subject to an initial similarity screening as part of the editorial assessment, before being sent for external peer review. The editorial team will use appropriate similarity detection software, online resources, and manual examination to identify potentially problematic overlap with previously published material, online sources, and other available documents.
Screening results are assessed in context. The journal does not use a single similarity percentage as the sole basis for determining whether plagiarism has occurred or whether a manuscript should be accepted or rejected.
Assessment of Similarity Reports
When reviewing similarity reports, the editorial team considers factors including:
- The amount and location of overlapping text.
- Whether sources are properly cited and acknowledged.
- Whether quoted material is appropriately identified.
- Whether the overlap occurs in the methods, references, standard terminology, or other sections where some similarity may be expected.
- Whether substantial overlap involves another author's work or the authors' own previously published work.
- Whether the overlap affects the originality, validity, or scholarly contribution of the manuscript.
A high similarity score does not automatically establish plagiarism, and a low score does not guarantee that a manuscript is free from plagiarism or other forms of misconduct.
Plagiarism and Inappropriate Text Reuse
Plagiarism includes presenting another person's ideas, words, data, results, figures, tables, or other intellectual contributions as one's own without appropriate acknowledgment.
The journal also considers the following practices potentially unacceptable:
- Copying or closely paraphrasing published or unpublished material without proper attribution.
- Using another person's data, figures, tables, or other materials without acknowledgment or permission where required.
- Reproducing substantial portions of previously published work without appropriate citation or disclosure.
- Reusing one's own previously published text or material in a misleading or inappropriate manner.
- Submitting substantially overlapping manuscripts to multiple journals or republishing substantially the same work without proper disclosure and justification.
Legitimate reuse of material, such as properly cited quotations, standard methodological descriptions, or appropriately disclosed reuse of the authors' own work, is evaluated according to its context and applicable copyright and publication requirements.
Duplicate and Redundant Publication
Manuscripts must represent original scholarly contributions and must not have been published previously, except where prior dissemination is permitted under the journal's policies and is fully disclosed.
Authors must disclose any closely related manuscripts, previously published versions, preprints, conference papers, or other publications that may overlap with the submitted work. The editorial team evaluates such cases to determine whether the submission constitutes acceptable scholarly development or unacceptable duplicate or redundant publication.
Submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal simultaneously is not permitted.
Editorial Actions
If the screening process identifies potential plagiarism, inappropriate text reuse, or duplicate publication, the journal may take one or more of the following actions, depending on the seriousness and circumstances of the case:
- Request an explanation or clarification from the authors.
- Ask the authors to revise the manuscript and provide appropriate citations or acknowledgments.
- Return the manuscript for substantial revision.
- Reject the manuscript before or after peer review.
- Suspend the editorial process while the concern is investigated.
- Refer serious or unresolved concerns to the relevant institution or other appropriate body, where warranted.
The journal will assess the available evidence fairly and give the authors an appropriate opportunity to respond before making a decision, where circumstances permit.
Responsibilities of Authors
By submitting a manuscript, authors confirm that:
- The work has been prepared in accordance with accepted standards of academic integrity.
- Sources, quotations, data, and other contributions from third parties are appropriately acknowledged.
- Any reuse of previously published material is properly cited, disclosed, and permitted where required.
- The manuscript is not under consideration by another journal at the same time.
- Relevant related publications and potential overlap have been disclosed to the editorial team.
Authors are responsible for ensuring the originality and proper attribution of their submissions.
Concerns Identified After Publication
If potential plagiarism, duplicate publication, or other serious concerns are identified after an article has been published, the journal will assess the available evidence and take appropriate action in accordance with its publication ethics policies.
Depending on the findings, actions may include publishing a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction. Any action will be proportionate to the nature and seriousness of the issue, and the journal will maintain an appropriate record of the decision.
Confidentiality and Fair Assessment
Similarity reports and related screening materials are handled as confidential editorial documents. The journal aims to assess all concerns objectively, consistently, and fairly, taking into account the nature of the manuscript and the circumstances of each case.
The final editorial decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor, in accordance with the journal's editorial and publication ethics policies.
