LoginRegister
CITI Universitywww.citi.edu.mn ↗
CITI SCIENCE 
International Scholarly Journal
ISSN (Print): 2788-7685e-ISSN (Online): 2788-7693Published by CITI University
Submit Manuscript
CITI Science Journal

Peer Review Policy

Overview

CITI Science Journal is committed to maintaining the quality, integrity, and academic rigor of published research. All manuscripts submitted to the journal are subject to editorial assessment and peer review in accordance with this policy.

The journal applies a double-blind peer review process, in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review process.

Initial Editorial Assessment

Upon submission, each manuscript is assessed by the editorial team to determine whether it:

  • Falls within the aims and scope of the journal
  • Meets the journal's basic requirements for academic quality, originality, and relevance
  •  Is sufficiently clear, complete, and appropriately structured for peer review
  • Complies with the journal's submission requirements and relevant ethical standards
  • Has undergone an initial screening for potential plagiarism, inappropriate text similarity, and duplicate or redundant publication

The editorial team will use similarity-checking tools and other appropriate methods to identify potential issues. Similarity reports are evaluated in context, as a similarity score alone does not establish plagiarism. Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements, or that raise significant concerns regarding originality or publication ethics, may be returned to authors for clarification or rejected before external peer review.

Double-Blind Peer Review Process

Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial assessment are sent to independent reviewers with relevant expertise in the subject area. The journal normally seeks at least two independent reviewers for each manuscript. Under the double-blind review process:

  • Reviewers are not informed of the authors' identities
  • Authors are not informed of the reviewers' identities
  • Authors identifying information will be removed from the manuscript file and ensure that acknowledgements and other identifying details do not compromise reviewer anonymity
  • Reviewers are expected to maintain confidentiality and declare any potential conflicts of interest before accepting a review assignment

The journal takes reasonable steps to protect the anonymity of authors and reviewers. However, complete anonymity cannot be guaranteed, particularly where research has been publicly presented or previously disseminated. 

Review Criteria

Reviewers are asked to evaluate manuscripts based on criteria appropriate to the subject area, including:

  • Relevance to the journal's aims and scope
  • Originality and significance of the work
  • Quality and adequacy of the research design and methodology
  • Accuracy and soundness of the analysis and interpretation
  • Engagement with relevant literature
  • Clarity, organization, and quality of presentation
  • Compliance with applicable research ethics requirements.

Reviewers may recommend revisions and provide constructive comments to help authors improve their manuscripts.

Editorial Decisions

Based on the reviewers' reports and the editorial assessment, the journal may make one of the following decisions: 

  • Accept: The manuscript is accepted for publication.
  • Minor Revision: Limited changes are required before a final decision.
  • Major Revision: Substantial changes are required, and the revised manuscript may be returned to reviewers for further assessment.
  • Reject: The manuscript is not accepted for publication.

The Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor makes the final publication decision. A favorable reviewer recommendation does not automatically guarantee acceptance.

Reviewer Selection and Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers are selected based on their subject expertise, relevant academic or professional experience, and ability to provide an impartial assessment.

Reviewers must disclose any actual or potential conflicts of interest that could affect their objectivity. Editors must also disclose and appropriately manage conflicts of interest. Where a conflict exists, the individual concerned will not participate in the relevant review or editorial decision.

Confidentiality and Ethical Responsibilities

Manuscripts under review are confidential documents. Editors and reviewers must not disclose, distribute, or use unpublished information from submitted manuscripts for personal or professional advantage.

Reviewers are expected to provide objective, respectful, and evidence-based assessments within the agreed timeframe. Any concerns regarding research integrity, possible plagiarism, duplicate publication, or ethical misconduct should be reported to the editorial team.

Review Timelines

The journal aims to conduct peer review in a timely manner. Review timelines may vary depending on the subject area, reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, and the extent of revisions required. The editorial team may invite additional reviewers when necessary to support a fair and informed decision.

Final Publication Decision

All manuscripts accepted for publication must complete the journal's editorial and peer review requirements. The final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor and is based on the manuscript's academic quality, relevance, ethical compliance, and the reviewers' recommendations. Submission to the journal does not guarantee acceptance or publication.