Publication Ethics
Ethical Standards
CITI Science Journal is committed to maintaining high standards of publication ethics and academic integrity. The journal expects authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher to uphold the principles of honesty, transparency, fairness, confidentiality, and accountability throughout the publication process.
All parties involved in scholarly publishing are expected to comply with applicable ethical standards and to act responsibly in the preparation, evaluation, and publication of research.
Responsibilities of Authors
Authors submitting manuscripts to CITI Science Journal are responsible for ensuring that their work is original, accurate, and presented honestly.
Authors must:
- Submit original work that has not been published previously and is not under consideration for publication elsewhere.
- Ensure that all sources, ideas, data, and materials obtained from other works are appropriately acknowledged and cited.
- Provide accurate descriptions of research methods, data, results, and conclusions.
- Ensure that all listed authors have made substantial scholarly contributions to the work and have approved the final manuscript.
- Obtain the consent of all authors before submission and agree on the order of authorship.
- Disclose relevant funding sources and actual or potential conflicts of interest.
- Obtain necessary ethical approvals, permissions, and informed consent where applicable to the research.
- Cooperate with editorial requests for clarification, supporting information, corrections, or other materials necessary to assess the integrity of the work.
Authors must not submit fabricated or falsified data, plagiarized material, manipulated results, or misleading information.
Responsibilities of Editors
The Editor-in-Chief and editorial team are responsible for ensuring that editorial decisions are fair, impartial, and based on scholarly merit.<o:p></o:p>
Editors must:
- Evaluate manuscripts according to their academic quality, originality, relevance to the journal's scope, and compliance with ethical requirements.
- Treat authors fairly, without discrimination based on nationality, institutional affiliation, gender, ethnicity, religion, political views, or other irrelevant personal characteristics.
- Maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and related editorial communications.
- Manage actual or potential conflicts of interest and arrange independent editorial handling when necessary.
- Ensure that manuscripts undergo the journal's stated peer review process.
- Investigate credible concerns regarding research or publication misconduct.
- Take appropriate action when significant errors or ethical concerns are identified in submitted or published articles.
Editorial decisions must not be influenced by commercial interests, publication fees, personal relationships, or institutional pressure.
Responsibilities of Reviewers
Reviewers are expected to provide objective, constructive, and evidence-based evaluations of manuscripts.
Reviewers must:
- Assess manuscripts fairly and within their areas of expertise.
- Maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts and review materials.
- Not use unpublished information for personal or professional advantage.
- Disclose potential conflicts of interest and decline review assignments when impartiality may be compromised.
- Identify relevant published work that has not been properly acknowledged.
- Inform the editorial team of concerns about possible plagiarism, duplicate publication, unreliable data, or other ethical issues.
- Provide their assessments within the agreed timeframe whenever possible.
The journal follows a double-blind peer review process, as described in its Peer Review Policy.
Plagiarism, Duplicate Publication, and Research Misconduct
CITI Science Journal does not tolerate plagiarism, inappropriate text appropriation, duplicate or redundant publication, data fabrication, data falsification, image manipulation intended to mislead, citation manipulation, or other forms of research and publication misconduct.
Submitted manuscripts will undergo initial screening for plagiarism, inappropriate text similarity, and duplicate publication. Similarity reports and other evidence are evaluated in context; a similarity score alone does not establish plagiarism.
When potential misconduct is identified, the editorial team will request an explanation or supporting evidence from the authors. Depending on the nature and seriousness of the concern, the journal may reject the manuscript, suspend editorial consideration while the matter is investigated, or take appropriate corrective action after publication.
Where necessary, the journal may contact the authors' institutions or other relevant bodies to seek clarification or request an investigation.
Research Ethics and Informed Consent
Authors must ensure that their research has been conducted in accordance with applicable ethical principles, institutional requirements, and relevant laws and regulations.
Research involving human participants, identifiable personal information, sensitive data, or animals must have appropriate ethical review and approval where required. Authors must provide details of the relevant ethics committee, approval, or exemption in the manuscript, where applicable.
Informed consent must be obtained where required. For research involving identifiable individuals or personal information, authors must ensure that appropriate consent and permissions for publication have been obtained.
Authors are responsible for protecting participants' privacy, confidentiality, rights, and welfare.
Authorship and Contributions
Authorship must accurately reflect the scholarly contributions of each individual listed as an author. All authors must approve the submitted manuscript and accept responsibility for their contributions.
Individuals who have contributed to the work but do not meet the criteria for authorship may be acknowledged, with their permission, where appropriate.
Changes to the author list, including the addition or removal of authors or changes in author order, must be justified and approved by all affected authors. The journal may request written confirmation before approving such changes.
The journal does not permit gift authorship, ghost authorship, or the omission of individuals who meet the agreed criteria for authorship.
Conflicts of Interest and Funding Disclosure
Authors, reviewers, and editors must disclose any financial, professional, personal, or institutional relationships that could influence, or reasonably be perceived to influence, their work or decisions.
Authors must disclose relevant funding sources and explain the role of funders in the research, where applicable.
Editors must ensure that manuscripts involving their own work, close collaborators, or other conflicts of interest are handled independently. Further details are provided in the journal's Conflicts of Interest Policy.
Artificial Intelligence and Automated Tools
Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and ethical compliance of their submitted work, including content produced or assisted by artificial intelligence (AI) tools.
AI tools must not be listed as authors. Where the use of generative AI materially contributes to the preparation of a manuscript, including the generation of text, analysis, images, or other scholarly content, authors must disclose such use in accordance with the journal's AI Policy.
AI tools must not be used to fabricate data, invent references, misrepresent research findings, or produce misleading content.
Editors and reviewers must protect confidential manuscript information when using digital or AI-assisted tools and must not upload confidential materials to external services in ways that could compromise confidentiality.
Corrections, Retractions, and Post-Publication Concerns
The journal is committed to maintaining the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record after publication.
When significant errors, ethical concerns, or evidence of misconduct are identified, the journal will assess the available evidence and determine appropriate action. Depending on the circumstances, this may include publishing a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction notice.
Authors and readers may report concerns regarding published articles to the editorial office. All credible concerns will be assessed fairly and handled with appropriate confidentiality. Further details are provided in the journal's Corrections, Retractions, and Appeals Policy.
Complaints and Appeals
Authors, reviewers, and readers may submit complaints concerning editorial decisions, peer review, publication ethics, or the conduct of the journal's editorial team.
Complaints and appeals must include sufficient information to explain the concern and, where possible, supporting evidence. The journal will assess submissions fairly and impartially.
Where a complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief, an appropriate independent representative of the publisher or another uninvolved senior person should handle the matter.
Editorial decisions may be reconsidered where there is evidence of a significant factual error, a misunderstanding of the manuscript, a procedural irregularity, or a concern about the integrity of the decision-making process.
Publisher's Responsibilities
CITI University, as the publisher of CITI Science Journal, supports the responsible and transparent publication of scholarly research.
The publisher is expected to respect editorial independence and ensure that publication decisions are based on academic merit and ethical standards rather than commercial, institutional, or personal interests.
The journal and publisher will take reasonable steps to address credible allegations of misconduct and to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record.
Implementation of This Policy
The journal reserves the right to request explanations, supporting documentation, or additional information when ethical concerns arise.
Appropriate actions will depend on the nature and seriousness of the concern and may include rejection of a manuscript, suspension of the review process, correction of a published article, retraction, or referral to the relevant institution or authority where appropriate.
This policy should be read together with the journal's Peer Review Policy, Plagiarism and Similarity Screening Policy, Conflicts of Interest Policy, Artificial Intelligence Policy, and Corrections, Retractions, and Appeals Policy.
